Q4 2009 Deal Volume Continues Upward Trend Transaction Volume and Transaction Value Continues to Recover - commentary by John Nowaczyk of Milestone Partners & ACG Marketing Committee A Trying Year for Dealmakers Ends…
In 2009, deal professionals in the Greater Philadelphia region closed 919 transactions valued at more than $156 billion. These figures represent a year-over-year decline in transaction volume of 18% and transaction value of 10%. Almost every sector participated in the decline, with only Utilities showing a modest increase in deals compared to 2008 and with Energy and Financials staying close to even with 2008 deal counts.
A notable bright spot can be seen in the 20% increase in M&A dollar value despite a 30% drop in the number of deals completed, reflecting an increased average deal size.
…with Clear Signs of Improvement Underway…
The fourth quarter included 224 transactions, translating to volume growth of 4% over Q3 2009’s 215 count, 3% over Q4 2008’s 217 deals and 27% over the Q1 2009 low of 177 deals. Although the trend is clearly positive, quarterly transaction volume is still 29% below the recent high point of 316 deals in Q2 2008.
Even excluding Blackrock's $15.6 billion acquisition of indexing titan Barclays Global Investors, area dealmakers generated $26.4 billion in total transaction value in Q4 2009. This represents an impressive 50 percent increase in the total transaction value over Q3’s $17.6 billion.
Another bright spot is that public offerings continued their climb out of a nasty trough (that bottomed in Q4 2008 and Q1 2009) and finished the year with two relatively strong quarters that enabled 2009 to come within just 3 deals of the 2008 total. Q4 2009’s 28 public offerings were also just 3 deals or 10% below the recent peak of 31 offerings in Q2 2008.
In Q4 2009 most industries enjoyed transaction volume that was as good as or better than Q4 2008, with Financials leading the way forward and only Consumer, Industrials and Information Technology still lagging significantly. As one might expect from the inherently more volatile sequential quarter comparison, the industry picture is more of a mixed bag versus Q3, with Financials, Healthcare, Materials and Utilities improving deal counts, but being offset substantially by declines in Consumer, IT, Industrials, Energy and Telecom.
…and Reasons for Optimism in 2010
In 2010, with gradually but definitely loosening credit, a slowly improving economy and more forward visibility for deal makers, look for more deals across the board and, in particular, for Consumer, Industrials and Information Technology to finally join the party in earnest.
To read about our members' Q4 2009 transactions and new member hires as well as GF Data Resources' Quarterly Survey Synopsis scroll down.
New to this issue, Should Have Been There: Insights from Our January Breakfast Meeting, found in the left column.
Transaction Value and Volume Comparison by Quarter
*To create a more realistic picture of the region's Total Transaction Dollar Value going forward, large outlier M&A deals will be excluded and listed within this footnote. For 2009, 3 deals were excluded: Q1's Roche/Genentech ($47 billion), Q2's Dow/Rohm ($19 billion) and Q4's Blackrock/Barclays Global Investors($16 billion).
Q4 2009 Industry Sector Comparison by Transaction Volume (Percentage Change Over Same Period Prior Year and Quarterly Analysis)
(Source: Data from Capital IQ)
About DealWire Philadelphia ACG Philadelphia's quarterly M&A report captures deal and transactional activities from around the region based on submissions by ACG Philadelphia members. Questions or feedback on DealWire should be directed to Jen Simons at jsimons@acg.org.
GF Data Resources’ year end report will be available in mid-February. GFDR principals Andy Greenberg and Graeme Frazier provide this preview for fellow members of ACG Philadelphia.
In the fourth quarter, deal volume rebounded markedly, though still falling well short of pre-recession levels.
Our year end report will include data from about 140 middle market private equity firms. These firms completed about two dozen deals in 4Q 09 in the $10-250 million value range with multiples of 3-10x TTM adjusted EBITDA.
The same universe closed only 12 or 13 deals meeting these parameters in each of the first three quarters of 2009.
However, deal volume averaged more than 40 per quarter in 2006 and the first half of 2007.
Click here for more information on GFDR, and on how to receive the year-end report.
Fairmount Partners LP (Charles Eckert and Tony Parisi members) provided strategic and M&A advice to a client finalizing a deal in Q4.
In December, Jonathan Gilbert was promoted to Vice President and Laura Bilazarian rejoined Fairmount Partners as an Associate.
Janney Montgomery Scott (Andrew Schmucker, Brendan Tierney, Steve Higgins, Brandon Eck, John Lindeman, James McNaughton, and John Damian members) closed 16 deals in Q4.
In fourth quarter 2009, Janney Montgomery Scott’s Investment Banking practice announced the hiring of Charles E. Mather as Managing Director in charge of Private Placements and Alternative Capital, John W. Damian, Director in the Consumer & Retail Group, and Peter A. Blackwood, Managing Director in the eCommerce and Digital Media Group.
Milestone Partners (Brooke Hayes, Adam Curtin, Geoffrey Veale, John Nowaczyk, Peter Batushansky, Daniel Ryan, Peter Elkes, Theodore Piotrowicz, Colin Raws, Craig Warznak and Kelly Widman members) closed 2 deals in Q4.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP (Barbara Shander and David Gerson members) served as legal counsel on 5 deals in Q4.
SSG Capital Advisors, LLC (Matthew Karlson, Mark Chesen, Michael Goodman and Victor Scott members) provided investment banking services for 2 completed transactions in Q4.
Featured Deal: Guardian and Argosy Acquire Sure Fit Showcasing ACG Member Deals
Interview With: Scott Evans, Managing Partner with Guardian Capital Partners and Michael Bailey, Partner with Argosy Private Equity on the recent acquisition of Sure Fit Inc.
On December 29, 2009, Guardian Capital Partners ("GCP") and Argosy Private Equity teamed together to acquire Sure Fit Inc. headquartered in Allentown, PA. Sure Fit (www.surefit.com) is the nation’s leading provider of ready-made slipcovers and related accessories. Its products provide an attractive and affordable solution for consumers who need to protect furniture from children, pets and general wear or want to quickly and cost-effectively enhance the appearance of a room. The Company sells through major national retailers, its own website and other channels. ACG: What attracted GCP to the opportunity? On December 29, 2009, Guardian Capital Partners ("GCP") and Argosy Private Equity teamed together to acquire Sure Fit Inc. headquartered in Allentown, PA. Sure Fit (www.surefit.com) is the nation’s leading provider of ready-made slipcovers and related accessories. Its products provide an attractive and affordable solution for consumers who need to protect furniture from children, pets and general wear or want to quickly and cost-effectively enhance the appearance of a room. The Company sells through major national retailers, its own website and other channels. ACG: What attracted GCP to the opportunity? It was a jockey and horse story. Sure Fit has a ninety-five year history as the market leader in ready-made slipcovers. Through these years, the Company has endured many economic cycles and itself has been knocked down and had to reorganize. However, through the leadership of today’s CEO, Hugh Rovit, the Company has not only survived in a challenging retail environment, but is thriving and well positioned for future growth. Today’s new normal, for at least the foreseeable future, includes a cost conscious consumer and tight financial markets. Sure Fit has connected with this consumer, has identifiable growth opportunities and is led by a team with a proven track record and relentless focus for pursuing profitable growth and creating long-term value. ACG: Other than price, what was important to the Seller in this transaction? Price was obviously important, but we prefer situations where price is not the only factor. With this transaction, speed, certainty of closing, and partnership with management were all critical elements of the deal. We recognized this early on and as such jumped out of the gates with an efficient diligence process. That is not to mean that we sacrificed the quality of diligence to save time; we used our experience in deal execution to our advantage and worked efficiently to compress months of heavy lifting into weeks. There are always those deals that require the round the clock work ethic, and this was one of those times. On the management front, we embraced the executive team immediately and rigorously tested our respective philosophies, company vision, and business acumen to conclude that there was a natural and lasting fit to our relationship. The process clicked, the people clicked, and despite the typical buyer/seller differences, we delivered a clean and efficient proposal that was accepted for reasons other than just price. ACG: You mentioned the importance of partnership with management. What where they looking for and what does Guardian Capital Partners provide? Similar to preferring deals that aren’t solely based on price, we also prefer companies (and management teams) requiring more than just capital. On a continuum of "active vs passive" approach to ownership, GCP is an active owner. That does not mean that we are micro-managers. On the contrary, we empower our management teams to deliver results and we provide support through strategic guidance, new and meaningful relationships, access to our proven tools and techniques over the years in private equity and operations, and, of course, capital. For example, the first 100 days of ownership ("F-100") are a critical part of our process and we work just as hard, if not harder, during this period than we do during our diligence phase. It is a period of on-boarding, strategic planning, and many other necessary activities to provide the backbone, governance and roadmap for success. ACG: Who were the critical partners in this transaction? At the top, we partnered with Wells Fargo Business Credit. This was strategic for many reasons, including that Wells Fargo was the incumbent lender and brought with them the knowledge and background with the Company. This was important given the reliance of speed and certainty for this deal as mentioned earlier. Argosy Private Equity was also a critical partner in this transaction. It had considered an investment in Sure Fit twice before, once in the late 1990’s and again in the early 2000 timeframe. In both instances, Argosy passed. This time everything was different - the performance of the business, the executive management team, and the attributes of the transaction and future of Sure Fit. Argosy and GCP have looked at opportunities together in the past, and are both active members of ACG (as is Wells Fargo). Sure Fit was an ideal opportunity for Argosy to partner with GCP by providing mezzanine financing and minority equity. ACG: Guardian Capital Partners recently announced a final close on its Fund. Did this play a part in the transaction of Sure Fit? The Sure Fit transaction was not dependent on our final close on committed capital. Nonetheless, we are extremely pleased to have reached our final amount for Guardian Capital Partners Fund I. It was obviously a difficult fund raising environment, and we believe our success in it is not only attributable to the quality of our team, but it also speaks to the market’s interest in our investment strategy to acquire lower middle market companies with the focus of building more efficient, higher performing and safer businesses. We feel fortunate to have dry powder to pursue opportunities like Sure Fit. ACG: What is next for Sure Fit? Our goal, of course, is to grow profitably. During our due diligence and as part of our F-100 process, we identified a number of revenue growth and operating efficiency opportunities, which are now being prioritized. We are also developing plans to accelerate opportunities to create product, customer and channel expansion. Sure Fit’s products, business infrastructure and management team are highly scalable and well positioned to take advantage of growth opportunities quickly and efficiently. As you can tell, GCP and Argosy are very excited about the Sure Fit transaction and are wasting no time in working with management to build value in this market-leading Company.
On December 29, 2009, Guardian Capital Partners ("GCP") and Argosy Private Equity teamed together to acquire Sure Fit Inc. headquartered in Allentown, PA. Sure Fit (www.surefit.com) is the nation’s leading provider of ready-made slipcovers and related accessories. Its products provide an attractive and affordable solution for consumers who need to protect furniture from children, pets and general wear or want to quickly and cost-effectively enhance the appearance of a room. The Company sells through major national retailers, its own website and other channels.
ACG: What attracted GCP to the opportunity? On December 29, 2009, Guardian Capital Partners ("GCP") and Argosy Private Equity teamed together to acquire Sure Fit Inc. headquartered in Allentown, PA. Sure Fit (www.surefit.com) is the nation’s leading provider of ready-made slipcovers and related accessories. Its products provide an attractive and affordable solution for consumers who need to protect furniture from children, pets and general wear or want to quickly and cost-effectively enhance the appearance of a room. The Company sells through major national retailers, its own website and other channels. ACG: What attracted GCP to the opportunity? It was a jockey and horse story. Sure Fit has a ninety-five year history as the market leader in ready-made slipcovers. Through these years, the Company has endured many economic cycles and itself has been knocked down and had to reorganize. However, through the leadership of today’s CEO, Hugh Rovit, the Company has not only survived in a challenging retail environment, but is thriving and well positioned for future growth. Today’s new normal, for at least the foreseeable future, includes a cost conscious consumer and tight financial markets. Sure Fit has connected with this consumer, has identifiable growth opportunities and is led by a team with a proven track record and relentless focus for pursuing profitable growth and creating long-term value. ACG: Other than price, what was important to the Seller in this transaction? Price was obviously important, but we prefer situations where price is not the only factor. With this transaction, speed, certainty of closing, and partnership with management were all critical elements of the deal. We recognized this early on and as such jumped out of the gates with an efficient diligence process. That is not to mean that we sacrificed the quality of diligence to save time; we used our experience in deal execution to our advantage and worked efficiently to compress months of heavy lifting into weeks. There are always those deals that require the round the clock work ethic, and this was one of those times. On the management front, we embraced the executive team immediately and rigorously tested our respective philosophies, company vision, and business acumen to conclude that there was a natural and lasting fit to our relationship. The process clicked, the people clicked, and despite the typical buyer/seller differences, we delivered a clean and efficient proposal that was accepted for reasons other than just price. ACG: You mentioned the importance of partnership with management. What where they looking for and what does Guardian Capital Partners provide? Similar to preferring deals that aren’t solely based on price, we also prefer companies (and management teams) requiring more than just capital. On a continuum of "active vs passive" approach to ownership, GCP is an active owner. That does not mean that we are micro-managers. On the contrary, we empower our management teams to deliver results and we provide support through strategic guidance, new and meaningful relationships, access to our proven tools and techniques over the years in private equity and operations, and, of course, capital. For example, the first 100 days of ownership ("F-100") are a critical part of our process and we work just as hard, if not harder, during this period than we do during our diligence phase. It is a period of on-boarding, strategic planning, and many other necessary activities to provide the backbone, governance and roadmap for success. ACG: Who were the critical partners in this transaction? At the top, we partnered with Wells Fargo Business Credit. This was strategic for many reasons, including that Wells Fargo was the incumbent lender and brought with them the knowledge and background with the Company. This was important given the reliance of speed and certainty for this deal as mentioned earlier. Argosy Private Equity was also a critical partner in this transaction. It had considered an investment in Sure Fit twice before, once in the late 1990’s and again in the early 2000 timeframe. In both instances, Argosy passed. This time everything was different - the performance of the business, the executive management team, and the attributes of the transaction and future of Sure Fit. Argosy and GCP have looked at opportunities together in the past, and are both active members of ACG (as is Wells Fargo). Sure Fit was an ideal opportunity for Argosy to partner with GCP by providing mezzanine financing and minority equity. ACG: Guardian Capital Partners recently announced a final close on its Fund. Did this play a part in the transaction of Sure Fit? The Sure Fit transaction was not dependent on our final close on committed capital. Nonetheless, we are extremely pleased to have reached our final amount for Guardian Capital Partners Fund I. It was obviously a difficult fund raising environment, and we believe our success in it is not only attributable to the quality of our team, but it also speaks to the market’s interest in our investment strategy to acquire lower middle market companies with the focus of building more efficient, higher performing and safer businesses. We feel fortunate to have dry powder to pursue opportunities like Sure Fit. ACG: What is next for Sure Fit? Our goal, of course, is to grow profitably. During our due diligence and as part of our F-100 process, we identified a number of revenue growth and operating efficiency opportunities, which are now being prioritized. We are also developing plans to accelerate opportunities to create product, customer and channel expansion. Sure Fit’s products, business infrastructure and management team are highly scalable and well positioned to take advantage of growth opportunities quickly and efficiently. As you can tell, GCP and Argosy are very excited about the Sure Fit transaction and are wasting no time in working with management to build value in this market-leading Company.